Bibliography
Abbott, A. (1988). The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.
Review by Michael Beach
In the vernacular of sociology, this book focuses on ‘boundary work’. Andrew Abbott looks at some of the more obvious points explored by others like how career paths become defined or known as a profession. He also looks at how professional groups form, compete, specialize and divide. Sociologically speaking, when a boundary is defined, however unclear, the result is division, insiders and outsiders. Abbott creates a framework to try to bring clarity around these issues.
After a literature review on professions, Abbott examines the base concept of professionalization. He describes what is and is not considered professional work, or better stated, what circumstances might be considered in defining it. He describes areas of professionalism such as claims of jurisdiction, implications of exclusionary efforts by those within a profession, and some of the sources of ‘disturbances’ that cause competition between and within groups of study disciplines. After discussing power dynamics (not necessarily in a Marxist concept of power) he speaks to larger social influences on professional organizations such as licensure, post-graduate credentialing, and national or international associations with specific codes of conduct.
The book finishes with several case studies around information science (librarians, computer scientists, etc.), lawyers, and various parts of the medical field. For example, he speaks to nursing professions in relation to medical doctors. In this particular example he notes how one profession is assumed to be somehow subsumed by the other. There is a form of hierarchy among medical professionals, even among branches of medicine itself.
Abbott notes that his system of professions is the process of “linking professions with tasks” (Abbott, 1988, p. 315). The system evolves as groups form around similar tasks, create some standards, then codify the profession. Evolution continues as specializations emerge within the group, competition begins over jurisdiction, and new professional boundaries result.
Abbott, A. (1988). The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.
Review by Michael Beach
In the vernacular of sociology, this book focuses on ‘boundary work’. Andrew Abbott looks at some of the more obvious points explored by others like how career paths become defined or known as a profession. He also looks at how professional groups form, compete, specialize and divide. Sociologically speaking, when a boundary is defined, however unclear, the result is division, insiders and outsiders. Abbott creates a framework to try to bring clarity around these issues.
After a literature review on professions, Abbott examines the base concept of professionalization. He describes what is and is not considered professional work, or better stated, what circumstances might be considered in defining it. He describes areas of professionalism such as claims of jurisdiction, implications of exclusionary efforts by those within a profession, and some of the sources of ‘disturbances’ that cause competition between and within groups of study disciplines. After discussing power dynamics (not necessarily in a Marxist concept of power) he speaks to larger social influences on professional organizations such as licensure, post-graduate credentialing, and national or international associations with specific codes of conduct.
The book finishes with several case studies around information science (librarians, computer scientists, etc.), lawyers, and various parts of the medical field. For example, he speaks to nursing professions in relation to medical doctors. In this particular example he notes how one profession is assumed to be somehow subsumed by the other. There is a form of hierarchy among medical professionals, even among branches of medicine itself.
Abbott notes that his system of professions is the process of “linking professions with tasks” (Abbott, 1988, p. 315). The system evolves as groups form around similar tasks, create some standards, then codify the profession. Evolution continues as specializations emerge within the group, competition begins over jurisdiction, and new professional boundaries result.
RSS Feed